Over the last few months we have been thinking of so many ideas around small cells and this is something that we thought. It looks very simple and straightforward and having talked to a few small cells experts, off the record, none of them seem to be able to see anything wrong with this concept. With the 'Small Cells World Summit' just round the corner I am sure this could be something worth a discussion.
I am explaining the concept using an HSPA+ setup but there is no reason why this would not work in an LTE Setup. This is a typical connection for HSPA+ Femtocell setup with the gateway acting as a concentrator for all Iuh connections and having a single Iu connection towards the core. I have not shown CS/PS connection separately for simplicity.
Advantages of this approach:
- The Femtocells are no longer really needed and the end customer does not require to buy a separate equipment, which is different for different operators.
- The phones can be working whenever a reliable WiFi connection is available, even if they are abroad without incurring costly roaming charges.
- Some operators that do not have a lot of spectrum available avoid using Femtocells as they can cause interference and black holes in the coverage.
- There is no worry of a femtocell being used abroad illegally thereby causing interference with spectrum in another country.
- Some security issues can be totally avoided and it would be worth for the operators that the keys being used cannot be seen by others.
- A lot of people use OTT apps like Skype, Viber, Whatsapp when abroad, being camped on WiFi to avoid costly roaming charges. This approach would mean that the normal Voice and Messaging becomes similar to OTT and can help operator avoid losing out to the OTT apps.
Disadvantages of this approach:
- WiFi spectrum is already congested and does not always give reliable coverage.
- Security issues would have to be looked in detail to make sure this would be secure enough. Since this concept is similar to creating a VPN between the phone and the gateway, I wouldnt think there would be any issues though.
- Roaming revenues are a big cash cow for the operators, most of them would be unwilling to lose this if the phones are using this approach.
I think this concept is more suitable for the Residential Femtocells rather than the other Small Cells (enterprise, metro, pico, etc.) and there will always be a need for them. The main reason being that on a large scale, WiFi is extremely unreliable, prone to interference and not future proofed. A new device may cause interference that may take forever to resolve. Operating a small cell in the licensed spectrum would always make sense and the reliability would be much higher.
If you think this makes sense please click the 'Useful' checkbox so that I know.
As a company we are always looking to engage with other companies to discuss similar ideas. If you are a company dealing with Small Cells and are open to discussing similar ideas, please let us know.
